Name A Star

Caveat Emptor - Let the buyer beware


Star Registration companies

The International Star Registry (UK) page can be found here - www.starregistry.co.uk.
The Official Star Registry page can be found here - Official Star Registry.
There is also the Universal Star Registry (no web page yet).
The Celestial Registry also has a webpage - www.star-gift-registry.com. They provide a Q&A page informing viewers about exactly what star naming in this way is all about.
No doubt more star registry companies will appear soon, especially with the year 2000 approaching... Whether you choose to have a star named officially, universally, celestially or internationally is up to you.

These (unrelated) companies provides a very wonderful service - for a small fee (50 to 80 dollars, or about 60 pounds) they will name a star for you. The star, selected by the star registry company (not by you), will be given the name of your choice; a loved one, maybe. An ideal gift for a Wedding, Christening, or even to remember someone who has passed away.

Immortalise loved ones in the heavens

Name a star? Sounds too good to be true? Yes, it is too good to be true.

Nice idea though it is, the registry company has absolutely no authority to name a star. For your money, you will recieve

Nobody outside star registration companies recognises the "new" name of the star. No astronomer will ever refer to one of these stars as "Sarah Smith", for example. The eminent astronomer Patrick Moore has denounced star registration companies in the UK magazine Astronomy Now. These companies have no more authority to name a star than I have to name a mountain.

These companies do not claim to alter the names of well-known stars, such as Sirius or Altair - they name stars that are as-yet unnamed. The stars are extremely faint and only known by index numbers or coordinates. I feel this is somewhat misleading (not necessarily intentionally), as when people think of the stars, they think of the ones that can be seen, not the countless numbers that are too faint to be seen.

Just imagine:

Adrian's International Mountain Registry

Yes, friend, for a small fee AIMR will re-designate a mountain to the name of your loved one. An ideal gift for a birthday, wedding, christening, bar mitzvah. Think how delighted they would be to know that from now on, a mountain such as Fuji, Snowdon, Everest or Ben Nevis will henceforth be known by their name.

It just doesn't really work, does it?

Another problem is that the star you are allocated is too faint to be seen with the naked eye, or even a decent pair of binoculars. A friend of mine used one of these companies to name a star as a gift for his niece, as a Christening present. As the mother was rather delighted with it, I thought it best to keep quiet, but had a look at the package supplied. I have a 4.5 inch reflector telescope, which is not terribly powerful, but cost a fair amount of money and is quite adequate for amatuer astronomy. I honestly do not think I could have seen the renamed star on even the clearest night using my telescope. It would certainly never be seen with the naked eye.


On 4th October 1996, I emailed the ISR (and more recently, the OSR) asking them the following questions:
  1. Which international astronomical organisations and official bodies recognise the new designations for the stars?
  2. How are the new names of stars made known to these bodies?
This is the reply from the OSR (which doesn't quite answer the questions) :-
> 1) Which international astronomical organisations and official bodies
> recognise the new designations of the stars?
> 2) How are the new names of the stars made known to these organisations?
> I look forward to your reply.

I will check on more perfect sources for you, but the stars that are released
for naming are stars that will not be studied by major organizations in the
astronomical organizations so these stars that can be named are documented
with the US Copyright Office and recognised worldwide.  The star coordinates
are registered and through The Official Star Registry, once a star and it's
coordinates are registered they cannot be legally named by anyone else.

There will be an annual book printed at the end of each year lsiting all the
stars registered to individuals.

I thank you for your interest and hope i've sufficiently answered your
queries. If not, come back and yell and I will ask higher authorities!  :-)


Best regards,
Lisa Singer
The Official Star Registry
http://members.gnn.com/ppnet/stargifts.htm

So, the OSR uses copyright laws to "name" a star (and, from reading their web page, it looks like the ISR does a similar thing), and the stars it does use are of no interest to official organisations (because they are too faint to be seen, possibly?). One problem with using copyright laws is that the copyright on something expires after a certain period (in the UK it is 25 years, I think), so the renamed stars are not even renamed permanently, and will come up for grabs again in a couple of decades. In other words, your loved one will not be immortalised in the heavens for all eternity (the companies make no such claim, but the very act of naming a star implies that it will be forever).


The ISR have made a lengthier reply. They requested that I make a few minor factual changes to this page which I have complied with (it is not my intention to make false statements about anyone, merely to show both sides of the story to anyone interested in star registration).
The ISR also would like me to make a few facts known, which I am glad to do: The full letter is reproduced here

Here is someone's actual experience of the ISR.
More information available here.
How are stars named? Can I name/buy one? - from the sci.astronomy newsgroup

NAMING AND BUYING STARS - WHAT YOU SHOULD KNOW


back to main page

Contact me at adrian